Homemade Peanut-Butter Cup Ice Cream

By Todd Barron @ FoodieCuisine.com

Cuisinart Ice-Cream Maker

My latest kitchen toy is a Cuisinart Ice-Cream maker.  It consists of a internal canister, which you place in your freezer for 24-hours prior to making the ice-cream, and an outer shell which houses the motor to spin the mixing paddle.

To make the ice-cream you freeze the internal canister for 24+ hours, mix the ingredients in an external mixer, pour into the canister, assemble the machine, and push the start button.

In 25 minutes you can add extra items to the ice-cream, such as chopped up candy or chocolate chips, and 5 minutes later you are done.  At this point you transfer the now-finished ice-cream to a new container and freeze for 2 hours.

You do not have to freeze it for 2 hours before eating it, but it will be less solid if you do not wait.  For my test I make a peanut-butter ice-cream with pieces of peanut-butter cup candy in it.  The recipe is as follows:

Peanut Butter Cup Ice-Cream

  • 1 cup Peanut Butter
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 1 cup whole milk
  • 2 cups heavy whipping cream
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1 teaspoon coconut extract
  • 10 small peanut butter cup candies, chopped

Preparation

  • Mix the peanut butter and sugar in a stand-mixer for 10 minutes
  • Mix in the whole milk for 5 minutes
  • Mix in the heavy whipping cream for 10 minutes
  • Mix in the extracts for 2 minutes
  • Place into the ice-cream machine (be sure the canister has been cooled for 24 hours)
  • Turn on for 25 minutes
  • Add the chopped candies
  • Run the machine for another 3 minutes, or until the candy is fully incorporated
  • Remove from canister and store in freezer, covered for 2 hours

The ice-cream turned out wonderful and I cannot wait to make more flavors.  It is soooo much better than anything I have bought from a grocery store!

Peanut Butter Cup Ice-Cream

Leave a Reply